SPEEDPOST

SEEA/P/PF/0705
July 17, 2007

Executive Director & I/c
RDCIS/ SAIL,
Ranchi-834002.

Sub: Failure to implement the order of CPFC and RPFC, Ranchi to HSPF Trust for payment of P.F. Revenue surplus for the years 1996-97 to 2000-2001 and 2002-03 to its members.

Ref.: Our letter No. SEEA/P/PF/0611 dated Oct 26, 2006

Dear Sir,

We are sorry to inform you that our above referred communication failed to elicit a favourable order from you for implementing the orders made by CPFC as per their letter dated 21.11.2003 and order by RPFC Ranchi vide their letter No. JH/RO/RNC/ EXM/ 935/06/1369 dated 14th June 2006 for payment of Revenue Surplus by HSPF, Ranchi to its members. Our above referred letter is a critique of the details provided by SAIL/RDCIS in letter No. RD/RI(05)/12 dated 28/09/2006 (along with the 13 enclosures) from GM (P&A) & Appellate Authority under RTI Act 2005. In our above referred letter we have established beyond doubt that both HSPF Trust and SAIL/RDCIS Management are wrong in withholding our hard earned money for over a decade now. Yet RDCIS and HSPF Trust have decided to ignore such a major issue in highly illegal manner.

We request you, once again, to kindly issue a directive to HSPF Trust for releasing our Revenue Surplus payments which is already held up now for over a decade. We are available to see you or your authorized representative to explain the doubts, if any. We hope to hear favourably from you by the end of this month.

Thanking You,

Yours faithfully,


(V.N.Sharma)
***********************************
SPEEDPOST

SEEA/P/PF/0704
July 17, 2007

Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
Employees P. F. Organisation Regional Office,

Bhagirathi Complex, Near Circuit House,Karamtoli, Ranchi –834001 (Jharkhand)

Sub: Failure to implement the directive of your Central Office letter dated 21.11.2003 and your own order No. JH/RO/RNC/ EXM/ 935/06/1369 dated 14th June 2006 by HSPF Trust for payment of P.F. Revenue surplus for the years 1996-97 to 2000-2001 and 2002-03 to its members.

Ref.: Our letters SEEA/P/PF/0612 dated Nov.01, 2006, SEEA/P/PF/0701 dated March 19, 2007, SEEA/P/PF/0702 dated May 11, 2007, SEEA/P/PF/0703 dated May 11, 2007.

Dear Sir,

We are sorry to inform you that all the above referred communications, including the ones under RTI Act 2005, failed to elicit a favourable response from you for implementing the orders made by your Higher Authority, the CPFC in late 2003 and your own order dated 14th June 2006 (referred to in the Subject) for payment of Revenue Surplus by HSPF, Ranchi to its members.

We also fail to understand the reason for your encouraging the wrong doers, i.e. the Chairman and Secretary of the HSPF Trust by opening these orders for negotiation by HSPF vide your letter No. JH/RO/RNC/935/07/6915 dated 30th March 2007 from your APFC (Sri S.K.Gupta). We are sure that conducting negotiation on final orders by the authorities are wrong both in law and in practice. As we have communicated vide our letter dated Nov. 01 2006 alongwith all the information provided by SAIL/RDCIS and HSPF Trust there is no justification for withholding the Revenue Surplus any more.

Under the circumstances we have repeatedly requested you in the past and we are doing it once again to issue directive to SAIL/RDCIS and HSPF Trust to release the payment to its members within a certain time frame. In case they fail to obey you can proceed ahead for derecognizing the Trust as per the provisions of law.

We request you, once again, to kindly issue a directive to HSPF Trust for releasing our Revenue Surplus payments which is held up now for over a decade. Keeping the long delay and silence on your part we hope to receive a copy of your favourable response positively by the end of this month.

Thanking You,

Yours faithfully,


(V.N.Sharma)